JEFF PITTMAN / UNITED STATES & CANADAFind your oilContact JeffTrack your orderAMSOIL Dealer #30734402
SYNTHETIC OILINDEPENDENT AMSOIL DEALERShop AMSOIL

MAINTENANCE GUIDE / JEFF PITTMAN

Synthetic oil myths and facts

Common claims about synthetic oil, including leaks, switching back, break-in, and mixing, compared with how lubricants actually work.

By Jeff Pittman, Independent AMSOIL Dealer · Updated

Products in this guide

Short answer

Synthetic oil does not cause leaks, you can switch back to conventional oil, synthetic and conventional oils can be mixed, and most new engines are filled with synthetic oil at the factory. You still need to change it on schedule and use the viscosity and specification your engine requires.

Myth: synthetic oil causes leaks

Synthetic oil does not damage healthy seals. Modern oils are tested for seal compatibility. In an older engine, switching oils can sometimes reveal a seal that was already worn or hardened, often because deposits that were partly blocking the leak are cleaned away. If an older engine starts leaking after a change, have the seal inspected.

Myth: once you switch, you can never go back

Oils that meet the same API category are designed to be compatible. You can change between synthetic, blend, and conventional oil at any oil change if the replacement meets your engine’s grade and specification.

Myth: new engines must be broken in on conventional oil

Many new vehicles are factory-filled with synthetic oil. Follow the manufacturer’s break-in instructions. Rebuilt or racing engines may call for a specific break-in oil and procedure from the engine builder.

Myth: mixing synthetic and conventional oil is harmful

Mixing licensed oils is not harmful, though the mix will have properties somewhere between the two. It is fine for topping up in a pinch. For the full benefit of one product, use it for the whole fill at the next change.

Myth: synthetic oil never needs changing

Synthetic base oils resist breakdown, but additives are used up and contaminants such as fuel, soot, water, and dirt build up. Every oil needs changing. The right interval depends on the product, the engine, the operating conditions, and the manufacturer’s maintenance schedule, and oil-analysis results where you use them.

Myth: all synthetic oils are the same

Base-oil groups, additive chemistry, viscosity, and approvals vary widely. Two oils labeled “full synthetic 5W-30” can have different specifications and intended service intervals. Compare the product data, not just the label.

Myth: thicker oil is always more protective

Protection depends on the right oil reaching the right places quickly. A grade heavier than your engine allows can slow cold-start flow and affect hydraulically operated systems. Use a permitted grade.

Frequently asked questions

Will synthetic oil make my old engine leak?

It will not damage healthy seals. It can reveal a seal that was already worn in an older engine. Have any new leak inspected.

Can I mix synthetic and conventional oil?

Yes. Licensed oils are compatible, and mixing is fine for topping up. The mix will have properties between the two oils.

Do I need conventional oil to break in a new car?

No. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions; many new engines are factory-filled with synthetic oil.

General maintenance information. Always follow your vehicle or equipment manufacturer’s requirements and the current product data. Questions? Email [email protected].

Related products

Confirm the exact application, specification, and package size in the vehicle lookup before ordering. These examples are not a fitment result for your vehicle.

BASED IN NEWPORT. SERVING U.S. & CANADIAN CUSTOMERS.

Let’s get you pointed
in the right direction.